It was a case that shook the world back in 1984 and still does to this very day, a hard working father of four children is still remembered fondly and hailed as a true American hero. That man's name was Gary Plauche. If you happen to be from America, that name will most probably be familiar to you. For those who might not be familiar with Gary's story this is where I come in with this post, so stay with me. Before I begin, I have to warn you that I will be talking about some very disturbing things to do with child abuse, I will try to be as sensitive as I can be and mention certain things briefly without taking away the true facts of the case. With all that being said, let's get into the background of who Gary was (may he rest in peace) and why he is remembered as a hero for the every man.
As I write this post, it is not lost to me that the anniversary of one of the moments that shocked the world back in 1984 has just been and gone. That very evening of the 16th of March 1984 has gone down in history and is still talked about to this day, so what happened? well, Gary Plauche, originally born and bred in Baton Rouge, Louisiana (USA) was a hard working father of four who was recently separated from his wife June. Gary had previously served time in the US Air Force and had undertaken various jobs to ensure that his family always had what they needed. He was, what a lot of people would describe as 'part of the backbone of America'. He was a fantastic role model for his children and with his son Joseph (nickname: Jody) he always tried to install the importance of hard work and self defence. With his father's support, Jody took part in karate lessons.
The karate instructor was a young man known as 'Jeffrey Doucet' (known as Jeff). Jeff was quite popular with the kids and the parents and came across as a nice, friendly person who would chat away with the parents no problem. He got on so well with everyone that people felt like they could trust him, especially Jody's parents, Gary and June. Jody seemed to be doing so well in karate and before anybody knew it, he'd been attending the sessions for a year. His parents were so proud of what he had achieved with the classes and all seemed to be well but what Gary and June didn't know, was that their 11 year old son was being groomed by a manipulative Pedophile.
Jeff had everyone fooled, the Mr nice guy act worked a charm and he was able to get around parents and children with ease. His focus on Jody was becoming more and more apparent and the little boy began to struggle with certain things that were happening, he was often left feeling confused and uncomfortable after being alone with Jeff.
Under the guise of a karate teacher, Jeff was using his position to get close to children, his crimes were pretty much hidden in plain sight. Sickeningly, he was able to grab children a certain way or get close to them in an inappropriate manner but play it off as a 'karate move', 'just a mistake' or 'sorry my hand slipped'. A lot of the kids were oblivious to what he was actually doing. He would play himself off as this nice, friendly guy who was just there to teach the kids but he'd use that as a cover for what he was really doing and that was basically inappropriate touching and grooming young children. His main focus was on 11 year old Jody and because he was very effective at manipulating people, he was able to get some moments alone with the child. Jody would later describe how Jeff would put his hand on his leg or try and grab him but play it off as a mistake at first, looking back he could see that this was part of the grooming process and Jeff trying to see what he could and couldn't get away with.
As months of this went on and it was coming close to a year, things escalated very fast with Jeff's obsession towards Jody. Jeff came up with a plan to convince Jody's mother, June that he wanted to take Jody for a short drive to which she agreed. Jeff had no intention of taking the child for a short drive, he had other ideas. Jeff decided to kidnap the child and took him to a motel room where he subjected the poor boy to a horrendous sexual assault.
Little is known about Jeffrey Doucet's background except that he grew up in poverty, one of six siblings in Texas. His childhood was quite tough where he had endured both violent and sexual abuse. He had a sickening interest in children through his teens and into his twenties. At the time he was abusing Jody he was only 25 years old. As we know with a lot of Pedophiles, they start off with just their sick fantasies, then they use materials like illegal abusive photographs of children, they then progress to physically harming a child and a lot of them go on to murder children too. Paedophiles are dangerous, terrifyingly dangerous to all children and they always want more, with them, situations always escalate.
Jeffrey Doucet was now at a point of the young age of 25, using the guise of a karate instructor to carry out his sick fantasies on young children and now he had progressed from groping children to kidnapping a young boy and keeping him in a motel room to carry out these sickening acts. Jody was reported missing, his parents were frantic, they knew who he was with and the search was on. Jeffrey was on the run with Jody and even dyed the child's hair black as well as telling him to pretend that he was his son if anyone asked.
The horrific nightmare thankfully came to an end when Jeffrey allowed Jody to call June and this call was traced. When the cops arrived, Jeffrey supposedly gave himself up without incident. After being checked over by medical professionals, Jody was soon allowed to return to his family but everyone was distraught about what had happened and they felt guilty for being tricked into putting their trust and faith into this person who was, in reality, a perverted monster. Jody was confused and very traumatised at what had been going on, it's difficult to imagine what had been going on in his mind at such a young age. It must have been very traumatic for him. Gary was beyond angry and felt powerless as a father, in shock and disbelief that this happened, he blamed himself even though this was something that nobody could have foreseen, Jeffrey was a skilled manipulator and knew how to con people.
Fortunately, Jody had no physical injuries and had come through the nightmare, alive and well but the psychological scars were there and he wouldn't fully realise them until he began to get older. It's frightening to think what else could have happened to Jody if Jeffrey decided that he wanted to end the boy's life as is often the case in these situations. Children who are abducted by pedophiles are often murdered as heartbreaking as that sad fact is. Maybe the cops were able to get to Jody just in time before Jeffrey decided to take they boy's life or maybe he planned to return him home at some point, nobody knows, but these thoughts began to haunt Gary and he couldn't bear the thought of how Jeffrey had fooled them all and harmed his little boy.
Gary was in constant contact with the authorities and he was focused on what was going to happen with Jeffrey. He knew that they were planning on bringing him back to Baton Rouge to face justice and when someone told Gary that Jeffrey was going to be arriving at the airport with the cops on the evening of March the 16th 1984, Gary quickly put a plan into action. The press, who had been following this case since Jody was reported missing, were also going to be at the airport to capture the moment when this disgraced paedophile was going to be walking out of the airport with the cops, in handcuffs.
Everything went as planned, the press were all set up waiting, the cops and Jeffrey Doucet had arrived and sure enough, they all walked out in front of the cameras. Suddenly, out of nowhere, as Jeffrey walked past a wall of public telephones, a man who appeared to be taking a phonecall, suddenly pulled out a gun and fired at Jeffrey's head. It was Gary, dressed in a disguise, he'd been on the phone to a friend when he said ''Here he comes, you're about to hear a shot.''
Gary had hidden a gun in his boot and had planned to go to the airport to shoot Jeffrey and that's what happened, right there, in front of live TV cameras and press reporters. It all happened so fast and you can view the footage on youtube. Gary even hung up the phone after he fired the gun, I know that is a silly thing to point out on the grand scheme of things but imagine that, you just shoot a guy and then you're like...''I'll just hang up this phone here,''. Sorry, I'm not trying to make light of the situation but it just goes to show you that even in that moment, Gary had manners. So Jeffrey was on the floor, and that was how it was. The cops rushed over to Gary (who they recognised straight away) and he never resisted, they bizarrely asked him ''Why, Gary, Why?''. What an odd thing to say and ask, when you have the father of a victim in front of you who has just shot the monster who harmed his son. I don't think you have to be Sherlock Holmes to figure out why he did it, if anything he was doing everyone a favour especially the children of Baton Rouge and elsewhere if that thing had ever gotten released back on to the streets. Pedophiles cannot be cured and that's a fact. I have included the link to the video of the shooting here if you are interested in watching it. There's no blood or anything like that on the video, it's all done pretty quickly and you just see Jeffrey Doucet fall down.
Jeffrey was rushed to hospital where he fell into a coma and passed away, no tears were shed. Gary was hailed a hero who did what any father would have done or at least wanted to do if anyone had dared harm their child or a loved one. In the eyes of the law though, Gary was in the wrong because he took the law into his own hands. Although it wasn't spoken out loud, you could tell that the cops were on Gary's side, the police hate pedophiles just as much as we all do and they could understand Gary's anger, the majority of people who knew the case, supported Gary's actions. He still had to face the law and after a very short stint in a jail cell, he was told he that he was going to be given a seven year suspended sentence with five years probation. He served no jail time except for that tiny stint in the jail when they held him whilst things were being sorted out. He was given 300 hours of community service which he completed without any issues by 1989.
As the years went on, nobody forgot what Gary had done in honour of his son and for victims everywhere and for parents of victims who had lost children to these monsters, it's what we would all do given half the chance. Jody struggled for many years to try and get his head around what had happened to him. Jeffrey had groomed him so much psychologically that when he heard that Gary had killed Jeffrey, he was angry at his father because in his confused and traumatised mind, his father had killed his friend. It took some time but slowly but surely, Jody began to unravel the pieces and the terrible reality of what had happened to him had become clear, he also began to understand why his father did what he did and soon grew to respect and appreciate Gary.
Jody wrote a book about the case called ''Why, Gary, Why?'': The Jody Plauche Story and talks about everything that went on all those years ago and his thoughts and feelings about his father. Jody became a bit of a hero himself, not just as a survivor of a horrific experience but the fact that he took what happened to him and tried to make a positive out of it all by going on to help others. He went on to university and became a great advocate and champion for male victims of sexual abuse and violence. He's given a few interviews over the years and recently described his father Gary as ''The Greatest Dad of All Time,''
Gary sadly passed away at the age of 68 on the 20th of October 2014 after a series of strokes but nobody ever forgot what he did that night all those years ago in 1984 to honour his son. When asked in an interview that was conducted not long before he passed away, if he regretted his actions and he said he didn't regret killing Jeffrey Doucet and would do so again.
It's without a doubt that Gary Plauche saved so many future children from being harmed by Jeffrey Doucet, he may have gone on to murder children had he not been stopped. The prison sentence that he would have been given would have not kept him locked up forever, there would have come a time when he would be allowed back on the streets and children would be at risk again. This story could have ended up very different as we have seen with a lot of similar cases where these monsters get away with their crimes, time and time again until there a number of deceased victims on their hands.
Gary will forever be remembered as a hero and the footage of that night is still viewed to this day, video clips of the shooting pop up everywhere, from Youtube to documentaries, shocking moments on TV where it's usually listed and now with various members of the True Crime community who have covered the case, the story lives on. I'm probably one of the last people to talk about this story as it is so well known, but I'm glad to have covered it. Some people may not agree but I feel justice was served in this case and Gary has my respect cause he was a proper Dad who just really loved and cared about his kids and the thought of any of them coming to harm really hurt him deeply, he couldn't let Jeffrey Doucet away with it and didn't want to see other kids harmed in the future.
Thank you Gary for what you did and Jody was being so brave and honest in sharing ykour traumatic story with the world. What a pair of great guys and it leaves me feeling (and I know it sounds odd) with a sense of triumph, like it all ended on a positive note because Gary is immortalised as a hero and Jody has become a strong survivor and also a hero who helps others.
RIP Gary, you will never be forgotten.
Further Reading & Sources:
- ''Why, Gary, Why?'': The Jody Plauche Story by Jody Plauche
- Gary Plauche: Article | New York Times
- Gary Plauche: Article | Los Angeles Times
- Jeffrey Doucet | Criminal Minds Wikipedia
- Gary Plauche: Article | ESPN
Thank you as always for taking the time to read my latest post, I hope you will join me here next time and I hope to see you elsewhere on my socials.
Stay safe & take care until next time....